Trade Review

MNQ1! No Trade2026-06-05

Share

The objective is not to grade the P&L. It is to grade the decision.

Loss · Small Loss

Charts

1 / 8

Trade Review

📅 Trade Review — June 5th, 2026

NFP Friday


🧠 Trade Narrative & Context

HTF Bias

Initial Bias: Bullish

Reasoning:

✅ NFP Forecast: 85K

✅ Actual: 172K

✅ Unemployment Rate: 4.3% (as expected)

✅ Average Hourly Earnings: 0.3% (as expected)

Based on the economic data alone, the market should have had fuel for a bullish continuation.


Overnight Structure

MNQ

Key Levels:

  • Weekly Low: 30,052.25
  • Premarket High: 30,260
  • 4H Bullish FVG:

 * High: 30,274.50  * Mid: 30,193.50  * Low: 30,112.50

Per the PMP, MNQ was sitting directly inside major HTF support. 


VIX Context

This is where the narrative shifted.

PMP expectation:

Bullish Equities Scenario

Needed:

VIX to remain weak and continue lower through:

  • 15.56
  • 15.50
  • 15.18

Instead:

VIX reversed higher after news.

  • Reclaimed its gap
  • Took out PM highs
  • Took out Daily High
  • Extended toward 15.89

This was the biggest clue that the bullish thesis was failing.


⚠️ Key Narrative Truth

Your initial bias wasn't unreasonable.

The mistake wasn't having a bullish bias.

The mistake was failing to adjust once VIX invalidated that bias.

You identified this yourself in your journal. 


📰 News Context

8:30 AM

Non-Farm Payrolls

Forecast: 85K

Actual: 172K


Unemployment Rate

Forecast: 4.3%

Actual: 4.3%


Average Hourly Earnings

Forecast: 0.3%

Actual: 0.3%


Market Reaction:

Instead of rallying aggressively:

  • NQ sold off
  • VIX rallied
  • Buyers failed to create continuation

This was a classic:

"Good news, weak price action"

scenario.


🎯 Trades Taken

🟡 Trade 1 — Long MNQ (YOLO Account)

Details

Account:

300K PA Account Number: [redacted]

Entry:

~30107 area

Position Size:

2 MNQ

Stop:

30042.25 low

Risk:

Very small

Expected Target:

30179.50 Order Block

30168.50 liquidity


Why You Took It

You observed:

✅ Liquidity sweep

✅ New low at 30042.25

✅ 1-minute OB/FVG reaction

✅ Strong bounce off lows

The setup itself was understandable.


What Was Missing

You made note of it yourself:

❌ VIX confirmation

❌ Strong displacement

❌ Higher high after reaction

Instead:

Price created:

30135.75

then failed.

That became a lower high.

That lower high was effectively the warning signal.


Outcome

Loss:

-[amount redacted]

Account Balance:

[amount redacted]

Screenshot confirms final result.


📊 Account Performance

300K PA #005

Starting Balance:

[amount redacted]

Ending Balance:

[amount redacted]

Daily Loss:

-[amount redacted]

Current Profit:

+[amount redacted]

Remaining Drawdown Distance:

Approximately [amount redacted]

(assuming standard [amount redacted]PA trailing threshold)


🧾 Summary

What Went Well

✅ You recognized you were off mentally

✅ Reduced size dramatically

✅ Traded only the YOLO account

✅ Did not force additional entries

✅ Did not revenge trade

✅ Did not move stops emotionally

✅ Preserved weekly profits


What Went Poorly

❌ Failed to adapt when VIX invalidated bullish narrative

❌ Treated the bounce as strength despite lower-high structure

❌ Entered before true confirmation developed


📊 Rule-Based Evaluation (1–10 Scale)

1. Narrative Alignment — 6.5 / 10

Initial thesis supported by news.

Adjustment after VIX rally was slow.


2. Setup Quality — 5.5 / 10

This was not an A+ setup.

More of a:

"C+ to B-"

attempted reversal.

Exactly how you described it.


3. Entry Confirmation — 6.0 / 10

There was reaction.

There was not confirmation.

The lower-high formation reduced quality significantly.


4. Risk Management — 10 / 10

Excellent.

This is arguably the best part of the day.

You recognized:

  • poor sleep
  • poor energy
  • poor focus

and reduced exposure accordingly.


5. Position Sizing — 10 / 10

Perfect.

2 MNQ in a YOLO account.

No criticism here.


6. Trade Management — 8.5 / 10

No interference.

No emotional stop movement.

No averaging down.

No chasing.


7. Time Discipline — 8.5 / 10

News day.

Waited for reaction.

No impulsive pre-news trade.


8. Emotional Control — 9.5 / 10

This is where I think you're underestimating how well you traded.

Most traders:

  • feel bad
  • lose first trade
  • force second trade

You did none of that.


📊 RAS Score (Rules Adherence Score)

Total Score:

64.5 / 80

RAS: 81%


🏁 Final Grade

B+

Not because the setup was great.

Because the decision-making was mature.


🎯 Main Improvement Areas

1. VIX Must Override News

Friday was a perfect example.

Good news.

Bullish expectations.

Yet VIX kept strengthening.

That should immediately downgrade bullish setups.


2. Lower Highs Matter

You correctly identified:

30042.25 low

30135.75 lower high

That was the market telling you:

"This bounce is corrective, not impulsive."


3. Trust Your Health Indicators

One thing jumps out from your journal.

You knew before the market opened:

  • weak in gym
  • poor sleep
  • mentally foggy
  • behind schedule

And because you knew that:

you traded smaller.

That's professional behavior.


💡 Key Insight From The Day

The biggest win today wasn't the trade.

The biggest win was self-awareness.

A year ago, a day like this probably becomes:

  • oversized trade
  • second trade
  • third trade
  • red day

Instead:

You recognized your condition.

Reduced risk.

Lost [amount redacted].

Protected the week.


⚖️ Final Verdict

👉 Good loss.

Not because losing is good.

Because the process was good.

You correctly treated this as a capital preservation day.


🔥 Closing Thought

What stands out most is that you never truly believed this was an A+ setup.

You knew it.

That's why it went into the YOLO account.

That's why size was reduced.

That's why you stopped after the loss.

The trader who blew up accounts in 2024 would have tried to make the market prove him right.

The trader I see in this review accepted being wrong for [amount redacted]and moved on.

That's a very different trader.

Written by Cory

Cory publishes the working thesis before the session, not after — this Playbook and Trade Review are part of that same documented process. No signals, no highlight reel.

Read the full story →